The recent court of appeal decision in item software uk limited v fassihi and others 2004 ewca civ 1244 has shed some light on this difficult issue historically, case law has been unclear, leaving unanswered the tricky question of balancing the individuals right not to incriminate themselves on. Type document page start 346 page end 346 is part of book title sealy and worthingtons cases and materials in company law authors l. Be that as it may, item software uk ltd v fassihi is clearly binding on me. The court of appeal so held, dismissing an appeal by the defendant, kouroush fassihi, from a decision of mr nicholas strauss, qc sitting as a deputy judge of the chancery division 2003 2 bclc 1 that he was in breach of a duty to disclose his own misconduct as a director of the claimant, item software ltd, in diverting items business to. Item software uk ltd v fassihi 2004 ewca 1244 kings. The recent court of appeal decision in item software uk limited v fassihi and others 2004. View all articles and reports associated with item software uk ltd v fassihi 2002 ewhc 3116 ch. In item software uk ltd v fassihi and others the court of appeal holds that a company director has a fiduciary duty to disclose his own misconduct and to account for secret profits. Directors fiduciary duty duty of disclosure duty of loyalty good faith entitlement to salary after dismissal apportionment act 1870. Mr fassihi was the sales and marketing director of item software. Lever bros ltd is distinguishable for the additional reason that mr fassihi was a director of item as well as an employee, which is the issue on which different views were expressed by glidewell j and robert goff lj.
For instance, in item software uk ltd v fassihi, it was held that the directors duty of disclosure of his own wrongdoing was an aspect of his duty to act bona fide because he could not have reasonably believed that it was in the interests of his company to be uninformed of that breach. Reliability software and services for engineered risk solutions from item software. Employer and employee implied duties university of stirling. Fassihi,2 in which the english court of appeal held that a director owes a positive duty to disclose his own. Fassihim, liddiardrams, international ltd, isograph ltd v. In item software uk ltd v fassihi and others the court of appeal holds a company director has a fiduciary duty to disclose his own misconduct and to account for secret profits. In accordance with the first facet of the obligation of loyalty it is a breach of fiduciary duty for directors of a company to exercise their powers of management and control otherwise than in good faith and in a way which they believe is in the best interests of the company. Item software is an acknowledged world leader in the supply of reliability software for engineering, including reliability, availability, maintainability and safety rams evaluation, and risk assessment.
Item software uk ltd v fassihi and ors, ca 2004 emplaw. That case concerned an alleged breach of fiduciary duty by an employee who was also a director of the company. It also illustrates the commonly used methodologies using a stepbystep example for a new project. In this context, and as set out in item software uk ltd v fassihi 2004 ewca civ 1244, the additional obligation of a fiduciary to disclose his own wrongdoing makes the remedy for a fiduciary to account for secret profits and for the diversion of corporate opportunities more effective. If your business is involved with reliability, availability, maintainability and safety rams evaluation, or risk assessment, you need to contact item software. Check the companys details for free and view the companies house information, company documents and list of directors.
The full text judgment in this case is available free of charge on the bailii website. The claims against the other defendants have been settled. However, uncertainties about the scope of the act have now been resolved by this court in item software uk ltd v fassihi 2004 ewca civ 1244. Does an employee have a responsibility to reveal their own misconduct to their employer. These negotiations failed and isograph terminated its contract with item software. Diversion of business when your employees become competitors. It was there held that a director was under a duty as a fiduciary to inform the company of a breach by him of his fiduciary duty. The case of bell v lever brothers ltd 1932 ac 161, authority for the proposition that there is no general duty for employees to disclose their own misconduct, had no application in a situation involving a director. In accordance with feature i, it is a breach of fiduciary duty for directors of a company to exercise their powers of management and control otherwise than in good faith and in a way which they believe is in the best interests of the company. Item qt iqt provides a customizable, crossplatform, multiuser, and open framework reliability and risk projectanalysis environment. Mr griffiths argued that the decision of this court in item software ltd v fassihi had changed the legal landscape. Shepherds investments ltd v walters employment and hr uk.
Item is a supplier of reliability software, which is concerned with the management and prevention of the risks of equipment. The recent court of appeal decision in item software uk limited v fassihi and others 2004 ewca civ 1244 has shed some light on this. Item software uk ltd v fassihi 2004, the court held that a director who breaches a fiduciary duty will be required to disclose breach of duty to the company if the duty to act in the interests of the company requires such disclosure. Firstly, it determined whether or not a company director was in breach of his fiduciary duty of loyalty by failing to disclose his own misconduct to the company, and secondly. The cambridge law journal the duty of loyalty of company. Type document page start 346 page end 346 is part of book title. Fassihi, the court of appeal considered two issues. The high court has held that a director breached his duty of fidelity when he failed to disclose details of a rival bidder for a contract which his employer was seeking to retain. I therefore proceed on the basis that a directors duty of good faith can. Court of appeal september 2009 directors duty to disclose own misconduct facts fassihi was a director responsible for sales and marketing. This section allows the court to use its discretion they are more flexible. Item software uk ltd appellants and kouroush fassihi mandy liddiard rams international ltd. However, in case the matter goes further, in my opinion mr fassihi did owe a duty of disclosure by virtue of his position as a.
Sep 28, 2019 item software ltd uk claimant distributed software products and at the relevant time, a major part of the items business was the distribution of software products to isograph ltd. Unknown to his employer, he was intending to set up a new company and had made a proposal to one of his employers customers that they should transfer an. The directors of item included a mr dehghani and the appellant, mr fassihi. Datacon item software uk ltd v fassihi 2004 ewca civ 1244. This is the trial of the issues relating to liability only in a claim by item software uk limited item against the first defendant mr. That breach was there the setting up of a new company and negotiating in.
Item software v fassihi duty of fidelity cipd hrinform. On 3 feb 2005 in employment law, discipline, staff monitoring. Appeal from item software uk ltd v fassihi and others chd bailii, 2002 ewhc 3116 ch, 2003 bcc 858, 2003 2 bclc 1, 2003 irlr 769 enforcement of confidentiality clause in contract of employment on termination. Item is a supplier of reliability software, which is concerned with the management and. Fiduciary loyalty, inside and out article by stephen r. Most of the discussion of the legal principles was in. To set a reading intention, click through to any list item, and look for the panel on the left hand side. Fassihi was employed by item software as a sales and marketing directorthe employment contract expressly provided that fassihi should not use confidential information belonging to the company for his own purposeitem softwares main source of business was distributing software made by isograph. In assessing a directors good faith, item software uk ltd v fassihi illustrated the courts use of objective measure to determine whether the director could reasonably have taken that decision in good faith. In item software uk ltd v fassihi, the court of appeal held that it was incumbent upon a fiduciary to disclose his own participation in the. Alexander fox and clare arthurs look at the implications of ghlm trading v maroo newey j held that much as a trustee must show what he has done with trust property, it is incumbent on a director to explain what has become of company property in his hands.
The claimants rely upon the decision of the court of appeal in item software uk ltd v fassihi and others 2004 ewca civ 1244 as authority for the proposition that a director is under a duty to disclose his own misconduct. You can change your cookie settings at any time but if you do, you may lose some functionality on our website. Item software v fassihi 2004 ewca civ 1244 oxbridge notes. Item software world leading developers of reliability, safety analysis and risk assessment software. Dont forget to deal with the alternative scenario of t having resigned. Jan 29, 2007 the judge considered this duty to arise both from his position as a fiduciary, and by reason of the implied term of fidelity see hivac ltd v park royal scientific instruments ltd 1946 1 all er 350. Facts and judgement for item software v fassihi 2004 ewca civ 1244. Dehghani was the managing director, and fassihi was the sales marketing director. Mary howarth arden, baroness mance, dbe born 23 january 1947, known professionally as lady arden of heswall, is an english judge she currently serves as a justice of the supreme court of the united kingdom.
Most of the discussion of the legal principles was in that context. We would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us. I refer to the judgment of arden lj in item software uk ltd v fassihi 2005 icr 450, with which the other members of the court agreed. Provided there is no restraint of trade clause prohibiting him from contacting clients of datacon, t would unlikely to be in breach of.
It is of critical importance to note that mr fassihi was a director of the company in question, with undoubted fiduciary duties towards it. Bell v lever bros ltd 1932 ac 16 item software uk ltd v fassihi 2004 i. Item software uk ltd v fassihi 2007 lloyds rep pn 17 court of appeal before lord justice mummery, lady justice arden and mr justice holman. In item software ltd v fassihi irlr 2004, 928, the court of appeal has just decided that a director who was also an employee had a duty to disclose his own misconduct as part of the directors duty of loyalty. For the purposes of this application, i accept that, in general terms, the claimants will be able to establish that. Item software uk ltd v fassihi and others university. Fassihi,2 in which the english court of appeal held that a director owes a positive duty to disclose his own misconduct to the company, the breach of which would give rise to a claim for remedies. Built on proven and recognized analysis engines, iqt is a revolutionary approach to reliability software, safety, and. We use cookies to give you the best experience on our website.
Reliability software and services from item software. Sinclair investments uk ltd v versailles trade finance ltd. Item software uk ltd v fassihi before lord justice mummery, lady justice arden and mr justice holman judgment september 20, 2004. Sealy date 20 publisher oxford university press pub place. Corporate governance and directors duties are hot continue reading directors. If you continue without changing your cookie settings, we assume that you consent to our use of cookies on this device. The latest product from item software is an extraordinary collection of new capabilities. Reliability prediction, fmea, fault tree, reliability block diagram, markov, event tree, spares optimization, maintainability, life cycle cost. But in a decision which is binding on me the authorities were comprehensively analysed. Director betrayed loyalty to his company solicitors humphreys. Fassihi and ors v item software uk ltd, 2004 ewca civ 1244, court of appeal on on 30th september 2004.
We are dedicated to providing our customers with the highest standard of products and after sales service. It was there held that a director was under a duty as a fiduciary to inform the company of a breach by him of his. Examination of the esv approach as a positive modern approach. Item software is the acknowledged world leader in the supply of reliability engineering software. The defendant was employed from 1 may 1995 and the contract expressly provided that mr.
501 228 1342 825 56 475 406 1151 1396 461 1154 967 890 1479 1208 327 1268 331 1400 1315 234 837 251 1320 345 874 949 325 1222 444 378 465 310 471 497 72 195 68 34 1489 546 501 388 607 467 772 689